The Cetiya Jātaka: The Lie That Sinks Deeper With Every Telling
CetiyarājajātakaṃKing Cetiya knows the truth but deliberately answers otherwise. A sage warns him again and again that if he sp…
Tiṇavatthārakena
When a group of monks had quarrelled until everyone had committed many offences, dealing with each one could have split them apart. The Buddha allowed all parties to gather together and confess their side's offences collectively in the assembly, excluding grave offences and matters connected with lay people.
In the Samathakkhandhaka of the Cullavagga, Vinaya Piṭaka, a group of monks fell into quarrelling and disputes, and in the process did many things unfitting for monastics, both in speech and in action. They thought that if they dealt with each other for these offences, the matter might lead to harshness, violence and a split, so they asked the Buddha what to do.
The Buddha allowed them to settle it by covering over with grass (tiṇavatthāraka). All the monks gather in one place and the matter is announced to the Saṅgha. A representative of each side first informs their own side, then confesses the offences of their side and their own in the midst of the Saṅgha. The commentary explains the name: like covering something foul-smelling with grass so the stench no longer spreads.
The method has clear limits: it excludes grave offences, offences connected with lay people, those who state a dissenting view, and those not present. The whole procedure is a rule for the monastic Saṅgha. What can be applied is the principle behind it, not an excuse for concealing serious wrongdoing.
Monks who were quarrelling, contending and disputing had done many things unfitting for monastics, both spoken and acted out. The wrongdoing was not on one side only.
After a long conflict, first admit to yourself that you too said or did too much.
The monks saw that if they dealt with each other for these offences, the matter might lead to harshness, violence and a split. Seeing this outcome is the condition for using this method.
Before dredging up every sentence the other person ever said, ask whether doing so will help or only deepen the rift.
All the monks must gather in one place, and a capable, competent monk informs the Saṅgha. It is not agreed secretly in small groups.
Ending a family rift should happen with everyone involved present, not by two people agreeing privately and telling the others afterwards.
On each side, a capable, competent monk first informs his own side that, if all are ready, he will confess the offences of everyone on that side and his own in the midst of the Saṅgha. Then the other side does the same.
In a dispute between two departments or two families, let each side talk among themselves until they agree before meeting.
The representative confesses the offences of his side including his own, for their benefit and for his own. Both sides do the same in the midst of the Saṅgha; neither confesses alone.
A joint apology works when both sides really do it. If one side apologises while the other only waits to receive an apology, it won't end.
Covering over with grass does not include grave offences or offences connected with lay people. Those still have to be dealt with in the usual way.
Agree clearly that only harsh words and small matters between you are being put down. Physical harm, financial fraud or anything that hurt outsiders must be handled separately and directly.
In this way those monks are cleared of those offences, except for grave offences, offences connected with lay people, those who state a dissenting view, and those who were not there.
If someone isn't ready to let the matter go, don't force them under the group's agreement. Respect that and talk with them separately.
Drawn-out conflicts in families or teams often reach the point where everyone has said harsh things, gone too far, and kept a long list of the other side's wrongs. If you start going through who said what and when, the conversation becomes a court case that never ends.
Covering over with grass teaches that sometimes the best way is for all sides to acknowledge together that "we've all made a lot of mistakes" and put the small things down together to preserve the relationship. But it must be done openly, with everyone present, and willingly.
The exceptions matter a great deal. Physical violence, abuse, fraud or anything that harms outsiders is not something to cover with grass for the sake of harmony. Those must be dealt with as they are.
Tap to read the actual passage on the page cited.
King Cetiya knows the truth but deliberately answers otherwise. A sage warns him again and again that if he sp…
The group of six monks went to watch King Pasenadi's army on the march. The king asked what use it was to look…
Rādha asks what is called "a being". The Buddha says it is one attached to the five aggregates by desire, like…
Two consecutive debates in chapter 2. The first asks whether a single mind lasts a whole day; the Theravāda qu…