Dhamma Principles › The Godhika Discourse: When Practice Falls Back Again and Again
The Godhika Discourse: When Practice Falls Back Again and Again
Training the mind

The Godhika Discourse: When Practice Falls Back Again and Again

Godhikasuttaṃ

Godhika practised diligently and reached a temporary liberation of mind, then lost it six times; the seventh time he reached it again. The discourse invites us to see repeated setbacks as part of training, and shows that despair at such times should not be carried alone.

6 points

In the Godhika Sutta of the Māra Saṃyutta (Saṃyutta Nikāya, Sagāthāvagga), Godhika lives on the Black Rock by Isigili. Diligent, ardent and resolute, he reaches a temporary liberation of mind (sāmāyika cetovimutti), which the commentary explains as a mundane meditative attainment. Then he falls away from it. He strives again, reaches it again, and falls away again, six times in all. The seventh time he reaches it once more.

The discourse records that, thinking of having fallen away six times, he thought of ending his own life. Māra, knowing the thought, went to the Buddha. The discourse then tells that Godhika died, and the Buddha declared that he had uprooted craving and attained final nibbāna; Māra searched every direction for his consciousness and could not find it.

This page gives weight to the first part of the discourse: effort that is gained and lost again and again, which many practitioners know well, and the lesson that despair at such times should be talked through and supported.

  1. 1

    Real, wholehearted effort Appamatto ātāpī pahitatto

    Each time, the discourse describes Godhika in the same words: diligent, ardent and resolute. His falling back did not come from laziness or carelessness.

    Applying it in daily life

    If you have put in full effort and still slipped back, don't conclude at once that you didn't try hard enough. Setbacks sometimes come from factors outside your intention.

  2. 2

    What is gained can be lost Sāmāyikaṃ cetovimuttiṃ phusi

    What Godhika reached was a temporary liberation of mind, which the commentary explains as a mundane attainment that can still decline, unlike liberation that does not relapse. This point is for overall understanding.

    Applying it in daily life

    Calm or improvement gained for a while may fade when circumstances change. See this as a normal part of training, not proof that what came before was wasted.

  3. 3

    Falling back six times Tamhā sāmāyikāya cetovimuttiyā parihāyi

    The discourse repeats each round: the first time gained and lost, the second time gained and lost, up to the sixth. The repetition lets the reader feel the weariness of starting over again and again.

    Applying it in daily life

    If you are starting over for the fifth or sixth time, the tiredness you feel is real and understandable. Tell someone close that you are tired, rather than forcing a smile and saying it's fine.

  4. 4

    The seventh time, he came back Sattamampi kho āyasmā godhiko

    After falling back six times, the discourse records that the seventh time Godhika reached that temporary liberation again. The capacity to return had not been lost through falling many times.

    Applying it in daily life

    Keep a note of how many times you have come back before. When discouraged, that number reminds you this fall is not the last time you will be able to get up.

  5. 5

    Thoughts in a hopeless moment should not be carried alone Yāva chaṭṭhaṃ khvāhaṃ sāmāyikāya cetovimuttiyā parihīno

    Thinking "I have fallen away six times", Godhika thought of ending his own life. The discourse does not say he consulted anyone at that time. This observation is our reading, not a statement in the discourse.

    Applying it in daily life

    When thoughts like "I've failed so many times, it will never get better" arise, take them as a sign that it is time to talk to someone. Thoughts in the darkest moments often cannot see the ways out that really exist.

  6. 6

    The ending of the discourse Godhiko parinibbuto

    The Buddha went to the Black Rock with many monks and declared that Godhika had uprooted craving and attained final nibbāna with consciousness unestablished; Māra searched for his consciousness and could not find it. There is a tension in the text, since just before he was still a learner, so the commentary explains that he attained at the very end. This point is for overall understanding.

    Applying it in daily life

    This ending speaks of one person's ending of craving in the scriptures; it does not offer ending one's life as an answer to discouragement. What we can use is the lesson of the first part of the discourse.

Try it in daily life

Anyone who has tried to break a habit, train in meditation or recover from depression often meets Godhika's pattern: better, then back; better again, then back again. Falling back does not mean total failure. The discourse states clearly that on the seventh attempt he came back once more.

The discourse does not say Godhika consulted anyone at that time. By contrast, in the discourse just before it in the same Māra Saṃyutta, Samiddhi, when frightened, went to the Buddha, told him what had happened and received guidance. When discouragement turns dark, take Samiddhi's path: go to someone you trust, a teacher, a doctor or a counsellor.

The ending is a particular case recorded in the scriptures, not an example to follow. If you or someone close to you has thoughts of ending your life, please talk to someone you trust, or call the Thai mental health hotline 1323; outside Thailand, contact a local helpline.

Sign in to keep track of what you have read

Sources in the Tipiṭaka

Tap to read the actual passage on the page cited.

Other principles worth reading

Log in to earn 40 merit points for reading this page