Dhamma Principles › Closing the Pāṭimokkha: Asked Three Times, Silence Is Confirmation
Closing the Pāṭimokkha: Asked Three Times, Silence Is Confirmation
Practice

Closing the Pāṭimokkha: Asked Three Times, Silence Is Confirmation

Samaggehi sammodamānehi avivadamānehi sikkhitabbaṃ

The end of the Mahāvibhaṅga and of Vinaya Piṭaka volume 2. After the seven ways of settling disputes are recited, the reciter asks the Saṅgha three times whether they are pure; when all are silent, they are held to be pure. Then comes the summary: this much of the Blessed One's training rules comes up for recitation every half-month, and all should train in harmony, in mutual appreciation, without disputing.

6 points

At the end of the Mahāvibhaṅga, Vinaya Piṭaka volume 2, comes the text monks recite at the Uposatha. The last section of the Pāṭimokkha is the seven ways of settling disputes (adhikaraṇa-samatha), methods for settling disputes that have arisen, from resolution in the presence of those concerned to covering over with grass.

When this section has been recited, the reciter asks the assembly three times: are you pure in this? Then he says: you are pure, and therefore you are silent; so I hold it. The same question also appears at the end of the other sections of the Pāṭimokkha.

Then comes the conclusion, naming every section as recited: the introduction, the four pārājika, the thirteen saṅghādisesa, the two aniyata, the thirty nissaggiya pācittiya, the ninety-two pācittiya, the four pāṭidesanīya, the sekhiya and the seven ways of settling disputes. It says that this much of the Blessed One's training rules is included in the Pāṭimokkha and comes up for recitation every half-month, and closes with a shared resolve: all of us should train in it in harmony, in mutual appreciation, without disputing. So ends the Mahāvibhaṅga and Vinaya Piṭaka volume 2.

  1. 1

    The rules end with ways to settle conflict Satta adhikaraṇasamathā dhammā

    The last section of the Pāṭimokkha is the seven ways of settling disputes, recited for calming disputes that have arisen: resolution in the presence of those concerned, resolution by recollection, resolution for one no longer insane, acting on acknowledgement, decision by majority, a penalty for the offender, and covering over with grass.

    Applying it in daily life

    Good rules for a home or team should include what to do when people disagree, not just prohibitions.

  2. 2

    Asked three times, not in passing Kaccittha parisuddhā

    When each section has been recited, the reciter asks whether they are pure, asks a second time, and a third time. Asking again gives anyone still hesitating time to reflect and a chance to speak.

    Applying it in daily life

    When you ask your team whether there are any problems, pause and ask again. Most people don't speak the first time.

  3. 3

    Silence is a weighty answer Parisuddhetthāyasmanto tasmā tuṇhī

    The reciter says: you are pure in these matters, and therefore you are silent; so I hold it. Each monk's silence is thus recorded as a confirmation before the assembly, not as having no view.

    Applying it in daily life

    When a meeting asks whether anyone objects and you stay silent, you have given your approval. Don't stay silent in the room and object afterwards.

  4. 4

    Every section is recited in full Uddiṭṭhaṃ kho āyasmanto nidānaṃ

    The conclusion names every section as recited: the introduction, the four pārājika, the thirteen saṅghādisesa, the two aniyata, the thirty nissaggiya pācittiya, the ninety-two pācittiya, the four pāṭidesanīya, the sekhiya and the seven ways of settling disputes. No section is skipped.

    Applying it in daily life

    When reviewing rules or agreements, read every item, not just the ones you do well.

  5. 5

    This much, every half-month Ettakaṃ tassa bhagavato suttāgataṃ suttapariyāpannaṃ anvaḍḍhamāsaṃ uddesaṃ āgacchati

    The conclusion says that this much of the Blessed One's training rules is included in the Pāṭimokkha, belongs to it, and comes up for recitation every half-month. The training rules have a scope everyone knows together, and are reviewed at regular intervals.

    Applying it in daily life

    A good agreement should state how many points it has and where they are written, with a regular review — say, monthly — rather than adding new rules on impulse.

  6. 6

    Train in harmony, in mutual appreciation, without disputing Samaggehi sammodamānehi avivadamānehi sikkhitabbaṃ

    The Pāṭimokkha does not close with threats of penalties but with a shared resolve: all of us should train in it in harmony, in mutual appreciation, without disputing. Keeping the training rules is learning done together by the whole community.

    Applying it in daily life

    When your group finishes reviewing its rules, end with what you will do together next, not with a list of who got it wrong.

Try it in daily life

This ending, which looks like mere ritual, has a structure any group can use: rules whose scope everyone knows, regular review, a chance for each person to speak if something needs fixing, and a close that recommits everyone to living together without disputes.

Silence here is not indifference but a confirmation before one's companions. The reciter takes silence as evidence of purity, so someone with something unresolved who stays silent has not avoided the question; they have answered it.

Lay people can use this pattern for themselves: on each observance day or at the end of each month, review the five precepts one by one and honestly ask which needs putting right, before resolving to begin a new round.

Sign in to keep track of what you have read

Sources in the Tipiṭaka

Tap to read the actual passage on the page cited.

Other principles worth reading

Log in to earn 40 merit points for reading this page