Dhamma Principles › The Nuns' Analysis: Once You Say "Very Well", Keep Your Word
The Nuns' Analysis: Once You Say "Very Well", Keep Your Word
Everyday life

The Nuns' Analysis: Once You Say "Very Well", Keep Your Word

Sādhūti paṭissuṇitvā

Criticising a badly sewn robe and promising to resew it but never doing so, agreeing to help settle a dispute and then doing nothing, and accepting the community's decision with "very well" only to complain later — three stories about the word we give.

7 points

The Bhikkhunīvibhaṅga, in volume 3 of the Vinaya Piṭaka, collects the training rules for nuns. Three origin stories share a common thread: saying "yes" or "very well" and then not living up to it. This behaviour is found in every family and workplace.

In the first, a nun made a badly sewn robe from expensive cloth. Thullanandā remarked that the cloth was fine but the robe badly made and sewn. The nun asked, "If I unpick it, will you sew it?" Thullanandā agreed, but once she had the unpicked robe she kept saying "I'll sew it, I'll sew it" without sewing it or having anyone else sew it. In the second, a nun asked Thullanandā to help settle a legal issue; she agreed, but neither settled it nor made any effort to have it settled.

In the third, the nun Caṇḍakālī asked the community for authorisation to give full ordination. The community considered it and told her it was not yet appropriate. She replied "very well", but later, when the community authorised other nuns, she complained that she alone was regarded as foolish and shameless.

  1. 1

    If you criticise and volunteer, follow through Sibbessāmi sibbessāmīti

    Thullanandā criticised the sewing and promised to resew it, so the nun unpicked her own robe. But Thullanandā kept saying "I'll sew it, I'll sew it" without doing so, leaving the owner with nothing but unpicked cloth — worse off than before.

    Applying it in daily life

    If you critique someone's work and offer to fix it, set a completion date too, since they may take apart what they had while waiting for you.

  2. 2

    Not doing it, and not letting anyone else Neva sibbeti na sibbāpanāya ussukkaṃ karoti

    The rule faults both not sewing oneself and not making an effort to have it sewn. The task one has taken on cannot move forward, because others assume someone is already responsible.

    Applying it in daily life

    If you know you can't finish something you took on, say so and hand it over as soon as possible rather than just holding on to it.

  3. 3

    Time allowed, and exceptions for real obstacles Aññatra catūhapañcāhā

    The rule allows four or five days, and the exceptions are a genuine necessity, searching and finding no one, working on it but exceeding four or five days, illness, or danger. The fault is putting it off without reason.

    Applying it in daily life

    When you promise something, give a realistic timeframe, and if an obstacle comes up, tell the other person right away.

  4. 4

    Agreeing to mediate, then disappearing Ehayye imaṃ adhikaraṇaṃ vūpasamehīti

    A nun asked Thullanandā to help settle a legal issue. She agreed, but neither settled it herself nor made any effort to have others settle it. The rule analysis explains that there are four kinds of legal issue: disputes, accusations, offences and community business.

    Applying it in daily life

    If someone asks you to help talk with the other side in a conflict, don't agree just to end the conversation. If you agree, actually arrange the talk.

  5. 5

    The fault begins when you let go Dhuraṃ nikkhittamatte

    In the rules on sewing the robe and settling the legal issue, the rule analysis says the offence comes as soon as one gives up the responsibility, resolving neither to do it nor to have others do it. One need not wait for harm to occur.

    Applying it in daily life

    Notice the moment your mind starts thinking "never mind" about something you took on. That is exactly when to tell the other person.

  6. 6

    Saying "very well", then complaining later Sādhūti paṭissuṇitvā pacchā khīyanadhammaṃ āpajjeyya

    Caṇḍakālī accepted the community's view that she was not yet ready to give ordination, but when others were authorised she complained, "I alone must be foolish; I alone must be shameless." The Buddha made agreeing and later complaining a pācittiya offence.

    Applying it in daily life

    If you disagree with a decision, ask for the reasons at the time or openly request a review. Don't agree and then grumble behind people's backs.

  7. 7

    Criticising real bias is no offence Pakatiyā chandā dosā mohā bhayā karontaṃ khīyati

    The exception states that if the community habitually acts from favouritism, hatred, delusion or fear, complaining about it is no offence. The Vinaya does not forbid objecting to unfairness that really exists.

    Applying it in daily life

    Before complaining about a decision by a manager or group, distinguish whether you see genuine bias or are simply disappointed not to get what you wanted.

Try it in daily life

"Yes" is the easiest word to say, but it carries weight. When we agree, others often plan around it at once, like the nun who unpicked her own robe. Failing to follow through leaves them worse off than if they had never asked.

The Vinaya isn't overly strict either: it allows time and makes exceptions for danger, illness, or when help was sought and not found. What counts as a fault is giving up the responsibility without reason.

The point about complaining later is worth noting too. If a decision really was biased, speaking about it is no offence. The problem is agreeing to someone's face and then grumbling behind their back without cause.

Sign in to keep track of what you have read

Sources in the Tipiṭaka

Tap to read the actual passage on the page cited.

Other principles worth reading

Log in to earn 40 merit points for reading this page